Earlier this year, Guadalupe’s 8-year-old grandson told someone at school he was very afraid. When Guadalupe, who immigrated from Mexico two decades ago, asked him about it, he confessed fearing what would happen if his mom or dad were taken away.
Guadalupe, whose last name is being withheld for privacy, fears she may have been too honest: It wasn’t necessarily going to happen, she told him, but it could be a possibility in the wrong place and at the wrong time. If it did, she added, she would take care of him and his younger brothers.
“Mama Lupita, so I should ask God to take care of my parents, so that immigration doesn’t catch them?” she recalled him asking in Spanish. “Exactamente,” she replied.
Last month in the Bronx, an ICE agent shot Oscar Belgal in the neck while his 5-year-old son sat in the back seat. The shooting drew new attention to how immigration enforcement affects children.
Children in immigrant families are living with that fear whether or not they ever see a raid, psychologists and immigrant families told Epicenter NYC, and it’s costing them the chance to simply be children. Experts say support groups for caregivers, and early help from a trauma specialist for kids showing signs of distress, can make a difference.
“The psychologist says they sense what’s happening to us,” Guadalupe said in Spanish, describing what she’s learned in free mental health workshops with Make the Road New York. “Maybe they don’t understand it because they’re kids, but they sense that vibe we have … ‘Oh no, it’s going to grab my arm, it’s going to grab me.’ That fear is always there.”
The lasting toll of living in fear
Young Latinos were already facing a mental health crisis even before the current surge in immigration enforcement. In the New York City Health Department’s 2023 Youth Risk Behavior Survey, Latino public high school students reported sadness or hopelessness, suicidal ideation and suicide attempts more often than their white peers. Psychologists note that living in fear of ICE adds to the strain for Latino youths.
That anxiety lingers even when families plan for the worst. Karen Porras, an immigration organizer with the nonprofit Las Doñas, said an undocumented friend arranged for her children to call and stay with their aunt if ICE did anything to her. Her children still cry at the possibility.
“My friend has already explained what they need to do, and they understand, but even so, it causes them a great deal of pain,” she said in Spanish.
That pain is compounded by the daily anxiety of hypervigilance.
“If you’re already walking around at a heightened state of stress, of anxiety and fear, and that’s your baseline, and then in addition to that, you’re exposed to some form of community violence, of course, it heightens it even further,” said Dr. Igda Martinez, a licensed clinical psychologist with Ambit Psychological Services.
Dr. Marybeth Melendez, a clinical psychologist who volunteers at a Staten Island parish, said the long-term harm isn’t a mystery. Past family separations, she said, have left effects that lasted generations. Studies of Japanese American families incarcerated during World War II found the effects of family separations lasted generations, she noted.
“We know these answers,” Melendez said. “And psychology has been telling us that answer doesn’t change.”
What to watch for
Young children’s brains aren’t equipped to make sense of traumatic events, Melendez said. They often lack the language and life experience to describe how they feel. Dreams are one way the mind tries to process those experiences. The mother of Belgal’s son told The New York Times the 5-year-old had nightmares in the days following the shooting.
A 5-year-old may not know why someone shot their parent, but “even a 3-year-old understands when someone is in danger, when someone is being hurt,” Melendez said.
Other signs include bedwetting or developmental regression in young children, outbursts, falling grades or pulling away from family and friends. Melendez recommends that caregivers of children who witness violence or are separated from a parent see a trauma specialist early, rather than wait to see if their symptoms persist.
Trauma travels beyond the scene
Children don’t have to see the violence to be affected by it. Martinez pointed to research conducted after the 2013 Boston Marathon bombings, which found that people who repeatedly watched videos of the incidents online showed more acute stress than those who were there. People directly involved tend to get help right away, she said.
“Your friends, your neighbors, your clergypeople … they come around our neighborhood, come and support us,” Martinez said. “We don’t think about the folks who are just reading about it or watching the videos.”
For immigrant news, that kind of news has been constant, including at least 29 people reported to have died in ICE custody this year. Teenagers can react especially strongly to an incident affecting someone they identify with, Martinez added.
“Any kind of community event like this can really feel like people like them are not safe, that their families are not safe,” she said. “The more identities you share, the more it feels like a direct threat.”
A family value
In the weeks that follow a violent or distressing event, Martinez said, it’s adults who should validate young people’s feelings. But many Latino families will say, “, ‘Oh, no te preocupes, no pasa nada’,” she said, which means, “Don’t worry, it’s nothing.” While it’s natural for caregivers to want to reassure young people, dismissing those real concerns, she said, “is the worst thing we could do for ourselves.”
Instead, families can say something like, “Of course it makes sense that you’re scared,’” she said. “ ‘We just saw this, or we know this happened to fulano (so-and-so).” To introduce mental health support to children without increasing their sense of danger or singling them out, she suggested framing it as “coaching,” or as a family value to get extra help.
But stigma can still get in the way. Guadalupe said many of her community members still associate seeing a psychologist with having severe mental health problems. Yet she thinks immigrants could especially benefit from mental health support, given the trauma they carry long before ICE.
“All this mental health stuff comes from abuse by … the very people around us, and many of us — well, back in our country — would never think that kind of thing could happen here,” she said.
Guadalupe has seen the difference in herself. A couple of months ago, she was walking with a friend when they saw officers at 103rd Street in Corona. As her friend panicked, Guadalupe reassured her while the officers walked past.
Guadalupe constantly urges her daughters to take advantage of the same free mental health workshops that have helped her, alongside her faith. Her oldest has finally agreed. She thinks her oldest grandson will also benefit from his mother’s efforts.
This Halloween, he asked if he could go trick-or-treating with her in Queens. She recalls him looking carefree beneath his werewolf mask, alongside his younger brothers dressed as Superman, a pumpkin and a Minion. It was a rare sight.
“I was so happy to see him like that, distracted, not in his head,” Guadalupe said. “It motivates me to go to those mental health workshops … We need to heal ourselves first so we can heal our kids.”
Where to get help:
- Spanish-language mental health resources: the city’s Hispanic and Latine Mental Health Resources guide
- Low- or no-cost care, regardless of immigration status: NYC Care, including mental health services
- Crisis support: call or text 988, available in Spanish
- Talking with kids: Epicenter’s guides on talking to kids stressed about ICE and talking with kids about violence
